Hey Mr. T.
Let me give you my opinion since I'm in a similar situation and just had a scar repair.
I had a bunch of other strip surgeries back in the mid 2000s that left me with a nasty scar from ear to ear due to the doctor not taking out high enough and another doc taking from the same area and making it worse. I also had a certain doc in NO VA try to repair it and he didn't do much to it (IMO he made it worse).
I just had surgery with Dr. Ron back in October just last month and we are doing a 2 part repair. Sides (from ear to back side on each side) in 1 surgery and the back middle in other. The scar is a tad smaller then yours but in parts is 1/2 wide and goes ear to ear.
Using this as an example (line being scar)
Ear <------------------------------------------------------------> Ear
First surgery I just did was taking out the scar from the sides (like below)...leaving just the back middle for the second repair.
Ear < Remove Remove ----------------------- Remove Remove > Ear
Dr. Ron and I both decided (and from my experience with ear to ear stitches), that it is better to take it out in 2 pieces because you aren't putting tension across the whole back and sides. I strongly suggest during a scar repair in 2 parts or even 3.
It's been a month now and I can tell you the following.
1. IMO, staples are the way to go. I just had my first staples ever with Dr. Ron and my lord I cannot believe at the 1 month mark how GOOD my scar looks. I know scars can widen later but right now, there is no widening, no redness, no nothing....but I think there is another reason for that...which is....
2. Dr. Ron used 2 things on me. #1 One was a substance called Vitrase which he used to help with the scar revision. Janna can explain it what it does but from my understanding it helps with making the repair less tight. #2 He also used ACell in the closure and I swear on my life, my scar at even 1 week looked like it was almost fully healed and more like a scar from 6 months out, not 1 week. After 1 month, all that is red is some of the staple holes and a minor faint redness in the super skinny scar line.
Dr Ron and I decided to leave the staples in longer also. We left all of them in for 14 days and took half out at the 14 day mark. Then we left them in for another 7 days and took the rest out on the 21st day. I think in scar repairs you have to leave them in longer. He said I could have taken them out at 14 but told me if I could deal with them for 21 days, then to keep them in. I think it made a big difference because I don't have ANY tightness and I feel the rest of the scalp stretched and not the scar during those 21 days. I can also tell you that I like staples better. I never itched at all with them and barely knew they were there after the 5th day.
I also feel that stitches cause shock loss and stretching from experience. Having the experience now of multiple stitch closures (tri and all) and now staples, I would NEVER go back to stitches. That's just
my opinion.
I would avoid Feller. I got a bad vibe from talking to him.
Go see Dr. Ron and Im sure he can help you. Im going back in Feb/March to have my middle back part of the scar removed..and Im chomping at the bit because again, I cannot stress enough HOW GOOD of a job Dr. Ron did..and yes it's only 1 month, but I never felt or had a scar look this good at 1 month. I would also suggest thinking about the Vitrase and ACell...I'm literally floored at how well my scar is healed..and it has to be the ACell. I also ate really really well during the 2-3 weeks and ate lots of healthy foods and proteins and avoids most fatty and bad foods. I think that helped but again that is just my personal opinion on the food (but some say protein helps scars heal faster).
Janna knows who I am. I've probably talked her ear off about how good my repair looks so far and she's probably sick of talking to me. And Janna and Matt are the best. Go to Shapiro...you won't regret it.